A New Volkswagen Phaeton Still Wouldn’t Make Sense

Phaeton or Passat?

Price a Bentley in America at just under a hundred grand and they won’t be able to make enough of ’em.

Price a Volkswagen at almost a hundred grand and no one will touch it, even if the only difference between the two cars is the logo on the grille. That’s the power of branding and a little thing called “perceived value.” Buyers love to feel like they got a deal, and they hate to feel like they got ripped off.

That’s why Volkswagen’s luxurious Phaeton remains a mystery. When it was for sale in the U.S., there was no value proposition. Prices started at close to $70,000 and quickly escalated. No one wanted a $100,000 car that looked like a Passat. It didn’t matter that the car was as luxurious and powerful as a Bentley. No amount of hand-crafted materials or double-stitched premium leather could overcome a poor price-to-brand value equation. Not surprisingly, the car didn’t sell here, and the Phaeton experiment was killed.

But VW wants to try again. With the exact same formula.

The Phaeton shares a platform with the Bentley Continental Flying Spur (I use present tense because the car still exists in other parts of the world). Needless to say, it has the luxury and engineering details to easily compete, and win, against cars like the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or BMW 7 Series. What it doesn’t have is a name badge that invokes feelings of lust and panache. In the United States, high price and a plebeian brand name is a recipe for failure.

The latest report on the future of the Phaeton, coming to us from Motor Trend, says that Volkswagen plans to replace the current Phaeton with another model and try again in North America. Maybe the company thinks we forgot about the first go and will suddenly be willing to open our bank accounts. Maybe it’s jaded because of the Jetta‘s success. Or maybe VW believes that Americans are simply ready to throw big money at regular brands.

I have no doubt a new Phaeton would be an incredible car. Motor Trend says it would ditch the W12 engine, use forced induction power and, of course, offer hybrid and plug-in models. It still doesn’t make sense, though, and it still would not succeed in the United States. Unless it came with a steeply discounted price or wore a Bentley badge.

Is Volkswagen nuts to even consider bringing the Phaeton back to North America?


Find Used Cars in Your Area at CarGurus

Used Volkswagen Phaeton
Used Volkswagen Passat
Used Bentley Continental Flying Spur
Used Mercedes-Benz S-Class
Used BMW 7 Series
Used Volkswagen Jetta


  1. I would say that they are because its like taking business from one place and putting it in another. Instead of them R&D on the new Phaeton they should put that money towards making the Bentley a better car. Volkswagen doesn’t sound like a luxury brand and thats one of the reason why this car isn’t selling. When people talk they rather say they have a Bentley or even a BMW over a Volkswagon.

  2. If VW owns Bently, what’s the point? It already IS a VW! I’ll never understand this brain disease called brand management, where otherwise unemployable college grads can convince a manufacturer will somehow sell twice as many if they just rename half of them. The true folly is that Volkswagon, which means “people’s car” is the exact opposite of what Bently represents.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.