What Car Would You Buy Tomorrow?

Porsche Cayenne, black

The car question posed last night wasn’t as easy to answer as I expected. I mean, I think about cars every day. In fact, I think about cars for multiple hours every day.

So when asked what I would replace my current car with if it suddenly died, I thought my answer would come swiftly and succinctly. Suddenly, though, my mind flashed with all the possibilities. I put myself in the mindset of this not being a hypothetical question and wondered what car I’d go buy tomorrow if I had to.

I had a dream a few nights ago that I was roaring through town in a new Jaguar, but after careful consideration, that’s not the car I ended up with in my fantasy purchase. I thought it would be.

Thinking about buying a car, even hypothetically, is a funny thing. It starts out as a simple thought, but sooner or later I end up browsing through the used listings and checking prices on cars I might, hypothetically, be interested in driving.

When prices are unexpectedly high, I happily chuckle and thank my lucky stars that I don’t need to buy a car. When prices are surprisingly low, I get excited and begin to wonder if maybe I really should get a different car.

A Porsche Cayenne for $11,500? Heck yes, I can look past the 139,000 miles on the clock! An ’09 Audi Q7 with 50,000 miles for $25,000? Hmmm… a 72-month loan should make that manageable.

There’s nothing wrong with my current car. Aside from the fact that it has 125,000 miles and a check-engine light that stays permanently illuminated, the car is perfectly reliable. It has brand new tires and a regular schedule of synthetic oil changes. I don’t need a different car. But now I kind of think I’d like one.

So what car would I buy if I had to replace mine? I’ve narrowed it down to either that Cayenne, the Q7 or a used BMW M3. Well, if budget wasn’t an issue, I’d wait a few months and spring for a 2015 M3.

Twin turbos and 425 horses sound pretty good. You know, hypothetically.

What car would you buy if you had to replace yours tomorrow?


Find Used Cars in Your Area at CarGurus

Used Porsche Cayenne
Used Audi Q7
Used BMW M3


  1. An $11000 Porsche Cayenne? Really? How’s the reliability on those? That’s pretty tempting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *