Do Your Tires Last as Long as You Think They Should?

worn tires

Who knew tires could be so controversial?

Back in 2009 we posted a blog about the need to replace new tires after just 20,000 miles. At the time I had a new vehicle that required new tires after just 22,000 miles, which turned out to be pretty common as evidenced by the people who left comments on the post.

In the years since, I’ve purchased other cars and other sets of tires. It seems there’s a new practice emerging of paying for a tire warranty. Are the days of 60,000- or 80,000-mile tire warranties gone?

I recently purchased new tires for my 2008 Audi Q7. The previous tires lasted about 30,000 miles, which wasn’t bad for an off-brand. This time I bought a new set of Cooper tires, but at the time of purchase I was offered the opportunity to buy a separate warranty. I declined, hoping that I’d get at least another 30,000 out of them.

My wife’s 2013 Subaru Legacy still has the original Bridgestone tires after 60,000 miles, but this will be the last season we can get away with not replacing them.

How can consumers know how long the tires they buy will actually last? Manufacturers are free to warranty their tires for as long as they want.

Consumer Reports is starting a guide for real-world treadwear expectations. The organization says:

Consumer Reports’ treadwear testing reveals close to half of the 47 all-season and performance all-season tires could be expected to last at least 65,000 miles, and a half dozen could top 85,000 miles or more. Interestingly, long life doesn’t necessarily bring much of a price premium, if any. Michelin was a standout in our latest tests. The three Michelin models we rated all met or exceeded their mileage warranty. But the longest-wearing tire came from Pirelli. We estimate that the Pirelli P4 FOUR SEASONS Plus could last a whopping 100,000 miles.

I probably should have done more research before buying tires for the Audi, but now I can be properly informed before buying them for the Subaru.

How many miles do your tires usually last?


Find Certified Pre-Owned Cars and Used Cars in your area at CarGurus.

Used Audi Q7
Used Subaru Legacy

1 Comment

  1. I have a 2011 Hyndai Elantra and have had to replace the tires every 20,000 miles! This is ridiculous! I’m on my 3rd set of tires and was told I need to replace them again so it’s 4 pairs at 80K. I have even brought tires that were rated to last 60K and guaranteed. When I took my car back to Sears after seeing they were bald, they said they would replace the tires with a different brand that wasn’t guaranteed and now they are worn out two years later. On top of that I was charged a $125 for them to put the new tires on and switch the sensors. Someone needs to do something about this! I have rotated my tires regularly as well as gotten alignments. The consumers are getting ripped off. My boyfriend has a Mazda CX9 and is having to get new tires every 20K too. If anyone knows of any brands that are lasting like they are supposed to, please contact me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.