• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The CarGurus Blog

Daily coverage of the world of cars.

  • Cars for Sale
  • Car News
  • Tech + Cars
  • Industry Insights
  • Research
  • Video

The American Car That’s Better Than a BMW?

Last updated: Nov 25, 2019 at 5:10PM
Published on: Jul 24, 2014 by tgriffith

Consumer Reports has drunk the American Kool-Aid.

The magazine, influential among car shoppers who commonly consult its ratings and recommendations, has made a decision that doesn’t make any sense.

I’m not saying car shoppers should dismiss the magazine’s advice, but I will say, on this topic, mine is better.

Sports sedans are meant to be comfortable, luxurious and, by definition, sporty. Sporty cars should be rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive and built to thrill and perform in any situation.

After yesterday and now today, it may seem like I have something against Buick. I don’t, but I sure don’t consider it a sports sedan brand, because it builds only front-wheel-drive cars. Consumer Reports says the:

Regal beat the Volvo S60 in a head-to-head road test. Ultimately, the Regal wound up finishing just one point shy of the class-leading BMW 328i and tied the Mercedes-Benz C250 for second place in the organization’s overall ratings of upscale sport sedans—while costing thousands less.

Of course it costs thousands less. The corner latte costs less than Starbucks, laminate floors cost less than hardwoods, and Buicks cost less than BMWs. That’s just the way of the world.

The Buick gets high marks in comfort, interior quality and handling, but it’ll never outperform the BMW. For Consumer Reports to suggest that the Regal is a better buy than a 3 Series or C-Class is to misunderstand what German cars are supposed to do.

While a buyer might get more bang for their buck with a Regal as far as features go, they won’t get the German engineering and driving experience of a BMW. If shoppers are looking to get the benefits of a BMW at a lower price, the only way to do so is with a used BMW.

Instead of a new BMW, would you rather have a used BMW or a new Buick?

-tgriffith

Find Used Cars in Your Area at CarGurus

Used BMW 3 Series
Used Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Used Volvo S60
Used Buick Regal

Filed Under: General Chat Tagged With: buick beats bmw, buick consumer reports, mercedes-benz, new regal vs bmw

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AvatarKyle Jennings says

    November 17, 2015 at 11:43 am

    Regarding your statement “won’t get the German engineering ….. of a BMW”, Regal is a re-badged Opel Insignia which received the European Car of the Year award and was engineered in Germany.

    http://www.caroftheyear.org/winner/2009_1/coty

Primary Sidebar

Cars for Sale

Screenshot of CarGurus.com homepage showing search functionality, menus, and imagery.

Footer

Copyright © 2005 – 2021 CarGurus, Inc. All Rights Reserved

CarGurus, 121 First Street, Cambridge, MA 02141

Read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

 

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in